Thomas Buttersworth (British, 1768-1842) H.M.S. “Victory” heavily engaged at the battle of Trafalgar; 84 x 142cm. (33 x 56in.)

This lot has been removed from the website, please contact customer services for more information

Lot 88
Thomas Buttersworth (British, 1768-1842) H.M.S. “Victory” heavily engaged at the battle of Trafalgar; 84 x 142cm. (33 x 56in.)

Sold for £ 74,090 (US$ 93,272) inc. premium
Thomas Buttersworth (British, 1768-1842)
signed 'T.Buttersworth' (lower left), oil on canvas


  • Provenance :- United Services Club.
    :- Sotheby's, 20th. March 1974, lot 111.
    :- Sotheby's 18th. November, 1987, lot 17, bought by the present owner (£31,000).

    Buttersworth exhibited 'The Battle of Trafalgar' at the British Institute in 1825, no. 206 (3 x 4.2 ft.).

    Throughout the long history of war at sea, the battle of Trafalgar was certainly the most complete victory of the age of sail if not the most decisive naval engagement ever fought.
    After a lengthy and frustrating chase across the Atlantic Ocean and back, Lord Nelson finally confronted the Franco-Spanish fleet off Cape Trafalgar on the morning of 21st October 1805. Admiral Villeneuve, the French supreme commander, had managed to combine the Spanish fleet with his own to give him a formidable thirty-three ships-of- war against Nelson’s total of twenty-seven. To compensate for this numerical imbalance, Nelson had conceived his famously unconventional battle plan to break the enemy line in two places and as soon as the opposing fleets sighted each other on the fateful morning, the British ships formed up into their two pre-arranged columns. Nelson himself led the Weather Division in H.M.S. “Victory” whilst his second-in-command, Vice-Admiral Collingwood, spearheaded the Leeward Division in the 100-gun “Royal Sovereign”. As the fleets closed for action, “Royal Sovereign” drew ahead and broke the line just after noon, almost half-an-hour before “Victory” could do the same when she was able to force herself between Villeneuve’s flagship “Bucentaure” and Captain Lucas in the “Redoubtable”. Close behind “Victory” was “Téméraire” and, within minutes, the four ships became embroiled in a tremendous struggle during which the 74-gun “Redoubtable” fought with great heroism against the two much larger British first rates. “Victory” pounded “Redoubtable” relentlessly, inflicting appalling casualties amongst the men on her decks, whereas above the carnage, the French sharpshooters stationed in the fighting tops of the masts quietly waited for their opportunities.
    At about 1.15pm., a sniper in the mizzentop of “Redoubtable” saw his chance, aimed and fired at the slightly-built officer on “Victory’s” quarterdeck made conspicuous by the glittering medals and stars on the breast of his coat. In the smoke and confusion of battle the marksman could not be certain that his target was Nelson himself but so it proved and England’s greatest hero slumped to the deck, the bullet having entered his left shoulder and lodged in his spine. Hastily carried below so as not to be seen by “Victory’s” crew as they fought on tenaciously, Nelson was taken down to the cockpit where he died three hours later in what would become one of the most immortalised scenes in British history. Unbeknown to all concerned, the battle was effectively won within half-an-hour of Nelson being shot when, at 1.45pm., “Bucentaure” struck her colours and Villeneuve surrendered. Even though the fighting continued for several more hours, the enemy was faltering and Nelson was told the scale of the victory whilst he was still conscious and able to comprehend the news. By the time the surviving Franco-Spanish ships fled towards Cadiz, eighteen of their number had been captured or destroyed and Napoleon’s bid for maritime ascendancy was in ruins along with his plans for the invasion of England.
    The identity of Nelson’s assassin remains a tantalizing mystery however and this was deepened, albeit unwittingly, by Thomas Buttersworth’s brush of artistic licence in this work where he portrays a lone marksman in the fighting top of “Redoubtable’s” mizzen mast. In point of fact, this platform – along with those on the ‘74’s’ other two masts – was crowded with sharpshooters making it impossible to pinpoint the individual who actually fired the fatal shot. When “Redoubtable” herself was taken, the vengeful crew of “Victory”, knowing precisely from whence the fatal shot had come which killed their beloved admiral, had doggedly fought and then put to the sword all those Frenchmen in the captured ship’s fighting tops thereby denying the assassin his survival. His identity unknown, there the matter might have rested but for the story of a French conscript named Guillemard who apparently wrote a colourful account of the deed for which he claimed credit and which took France by storm when published. In time, Guillemard and his exploits were exposed as a totally fictional hoax even though, for a while at least, the would-be sniper enjoyed a notoriety amongst his own countrymen which then took many years to fade from the popular memory. Meanwhile, in the annals of the Royal Navy, another tradition grew up that the marksman who fired the shot which killed Nelson was himself shot by one of “Victory’s” young midshipmen and seen to fall back dead.
Thomas Buttersworth (British, 1768-1842) H.M.S. “Victory” heavily engaged at the battle of Trafalgar; 84 x 142cm. (33 x 56in.)
Auction information

This sale is now finished. If you are interested in consigning in future sales, please contact the specialist department. If you have queries about lots purchased in this sale, please contact customer services.

Buyers' Obligations


If you have any complaints or questions about the Conditions of Sale, please contact your nearest customer services team.

Buyers' Premium and Charges

For all Sales categories, buyer's premium excluding Cars, Motorbikes, Wine, Whisky and Coin & Medal sales, will be as follows:

Buyer's Premium Rates
27.5% on the first £2,500 of the hammer price;
25% of the hammer price of amounts in excess of £2,500 up to and including £300,000;
20% of the hammer price of amounts in excess of £300,000 up to and including £3,000,000;
and 13.9% of the hammer price of any amounts in excess of £3,000,000.

VAT at the current rate of 20% will be added to the Buyer's Premium and charges excluding Artists Resale Right.

Payment Notices

For payment information please refer to the sale catalog.

Shipping Notices

For information and estimates on domestic and international shipping as well as export licenses please contact Bonhams Shipping Department.