1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116
Lot 187
The 1952 Earls Court Motor Show, 1953 Sebring 12 Hours,1952 Frazer-Nash Le Mans Replica MkII Competition Model Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116
Sold for US$ 1,001,000 inc. premium
Auction Details
1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116 1952 Frazer Nash Le Mans Replica Mk2 2-Seat Sports Racer  Chassis no. 421/200/174 Engine no. BS1/116
Lot Details
The 1952 Earls Court Motor Show, 1953 Sebring 12 Hours
1952 Frazer-Nash Le Mans Replica MkII Competition Model
Chassis no. 421/200/174
Engine no. BS1/116
1,971cc DOHC Bristol Inline 6-Cylinder Engine
150bhp at 5,750rpm
4-Speed Manual Transmission
4-Wheel Hydraulic Drum Brakes

*One of the most original Le Mans Replicas in existence
*1952 Earls Court Motor Show feature car
*1953 Sebring 12 Hour participant
*Ex-Stuart "Duke" Donaldson and George Waltman
*Two owners from new—in present ownership since 1959



The Frazer-Nash Le Mans Replica MkII

Introduced as the High Speed Competition Model in 1948, a handful of examples were produced until TMX 545 powered to a 3rd place overall finish in the running of Le Mans 24 Hours the following year. Henceforth, the subsequent examples produced were named "Le Mans Replicas" to honor the strong performance in '49. 21 of these Le Mans Replicas were built but advancements in competition required further upgrading. In 1952, an entirely new chassis frame composed of two parallel four inch diameter tubes with similarly sized cross members replaced the old BMW 328-based architecture. While the new setup was lighter, thanks to the greater simplicity of its construction, there was some debate as to whether it was better than the old chassis. The newly christened Mark II rounded out the production run with a further eight cars. Production of the Le Mans Replica series ceased in 1954.


The Motorcar Offered

This unrestored and completely original Le Mans Replica Mark II has had only two owners from new and an incredible history both on and off the track. Cars do not survive 61 years in such pristine nick without careful attention and care, both of which the Frazer-Nash has received in spades.

The second MkII produced, serial number 174 was promptly debuted at the 1952 Earls Court Motor Show in October of that year, and was featured extensively in Frazer-Nash's own brochure for the new MkII. Clothed in white paint and red leather, the car was first purchased by American Frazer-Nash agent Stuart "Duke" Donaldson and delivered in December, 1952. Donaldson, a New Yorker and accomplished racer in his own right, had entered a Le Mans Replica, serial number 421/100/160, in the premier running of the Sebring 12 Hours in 1952 (the first Sebring race, in 1950, had a duration of six hours). With Larry Kulok and Harry Grey at the wheel, Duke's Nash swept the field of Ferraris, Porsches, and Cunninghams to come in first place overall. Looking for a repeat of his performance the following year, Duke hoped his new MkII would be his ticket to back-to-back victories. Showing just as it had on the podium at Earls Court, Duke's MkII entered the race with a red number '1' gracing its sides and with Tony Bonadies and George Rice—both accomplished circle track racers who had found success in the Midwest and Northeast—at the wheel .

Unfortunately, another victory was not to be had, as ten laps in the clutch failed and could not be fully repaired. In the mid-50s while the car was still actively competing, it was painted red—to match the '52 Sebring winning car—and the engine was moved back six inches to improve the handling characteristics, a change that would prove to be effective. Reports that a De Dion rear axle was also fitted at this time are spurious as the original live axle remains installed on the car with no records of this change ever being made.

In 1959, George Waltman, who had been racing for some time and was becoming a well known figure on the racing scene, purchased 174 and a wealth of spares from Duke for $1500. Waltman later remarked that he had, "bought it in favor of a Ferrari that Luigi Chinetti had offered me at the time. I've never been sorry of the choice..."

A true gentleman racer, he was known to bring a no-nonsense attitude to the sport while at the same time driving with a keen eye on having a good time. His fame would grow greatly with his solo endurance racing exploits. At the 1961 Sebring 12 Hours, his completion of the race in his Triumph TR3 would earn him the headline "Iron Man of Queens" in The New York Times with a race review that mostly talked about Waltman and only briefly mentioned the actual winners. George's legend would be cemented with his solo running of the 24 Hours of Daytona seven years later, when he drove his Morgan Plus Four down from New York City to Florida and ran the 24 hours in its entirety. Despite having to stop for an hour after every four hours in the car to satisfy FIA rules, he finished only five laps behind James Garner's AIR team Corvette, piloted by four professional racers. After the race George changed the oil and drove back to New York in his Morgan, the only entrant to complete the grueling 24 hours of Daytona without a co-driver, and without a pit crew. He was the consummate gentleman racer – and a very good one at that.

George Waltman considered his Frazer-Nash to be the crown jewel of his collection. Driving the car sparingly at Watkins Glen, Lime Rock, Bridgehampton, and various other tracks, it still received less use than his other racers. Though he was a man of simple pleasures and modest means he didn't coddle the car in a plastic bubble. In a 2001 letter to Frazer-Nash USA registrar Bob Schmitt, Waltman said, "I always drove it on the road to all the race events, with my camping equipment aboard. It never let me down, and I always was able to drive it back from the events I ran it in."

In April of 1963, Waltman drove the Frazer-Nash to its second major show, the New York Auto Show, where this time it was shown as a decade old artifact. Later that year, Car and Driver reviewed the Le Mans Replica in the July issue. While the cover featured a different car, the article itself was ladened with photos of Waltman's Frazer-Nash about which the C/D editors waxed about the car:

The racing car feel of brutal, open masculinity has never been more gently arrived at. It's the kind of head-turner that almost gets embarrassing to drive, and we found ourselves whipping along with an enormous grin.

The last big outing for the Nash was in 1975 when George shipped the car to the UK for the Frazer-Nash 50th Anniversary Gathering at Castle Combe. It is likely he would have driven it there, had that been an option. Into the later '70s and '80s the car continued to be gently used and shown—George's son fondly recalls riding in it as a boy in the early '80s—but by the early '90s the car was carefully stored on Waltman's Pennsylvania farm, rarely driven.

Quietly owning the car, George still occasionally spoke publicly about his prized Frazer-Nash, most strikingly in his scathing rebuke to a review of a Le Mans Replica Replica. His edited letter appeared in the March 1999 issue of Classic & Sports Car noting that he'd "rather own a real Fiat 500 than a fake FN."

Waltman's practical ownership and frugal but spirited use of his Le Mans Replica MkII has preserved the car in the remarkable condition in which it shows today. Any modifications from its original delivery specification, including the color change, the repositioning of the engine, and the replacement of the transmission housing with a painted NOS unit were all completed in 1960 or prior. 174's stunning preservation status is best summed in George Waltman's own words:

I still have it fitted with Dunlop diamond tred (sic) race tyres. The interior is still original, and actually, nothing has been butchered up or screwed around with since it left the Sebring Circuit.

With George's passing in January of this year, it has come time for his Frazer-Nash to move on to its third owner from new. One of the last true American gentlemen racers, George raced for fun and enjoyment, becoming a legend in his own time thanks to his unrepeatable accomplishments. His Frazer-Nash was the crowning achievement of his collecting career and the jewel of his garage.

Le Mans Replicas are remarkable for their eligibility for the most prestigious vintage events, including the Mille Miglia, Targa Florio, Le Mans Classic, California Mille, Colorado Grand, and many more. George certainly proved its dual-purpose nature as a mount with which to drive to the track, race, and then drive home. With its storied history, stunningly authentic originality, and mountains of character, one can only hope that, in George's own words, "the FN finds an honest home."

Footnotes

  • Please note that this vehicle is titled under its engine number and as a 1953

Saleroom notices

  • Please note, the original engine for this vehicle was removed in the mid-1950s during 'Duke' Donaldson's ownership and replaced with a later Bristol motor, engine number 100D2/1110, but retaining its original heads from engine number BS1/116. The original engine, which came with the car when George Waltman purchased it, will accompany the car and may be collected by the buyer at his expense following the auction. Please note that the title for this vehicle is in transit.
Activities
Auction information

This auction is now finished.

If you are interested in consigning in future auctions, please email us at motors.us@bonhams.com or request a complimentary motorcar appraisal.

If you have queries about lots purchased in this auction, please contact customer services.

Buyers' Obligations

ALL BIDDERS MUST AGREE THAT THEY HAVE READ AND UNDERSTOOD BONHAMS' CONDITIONS OF SALE AND AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THEM, AND AGREE TO PAY THE BUYER'S PREMIUM AND ANY OTHER CHARGES MENTIONED IN THE NOTICE TO BIDDERS. THIS AFFECTS THE BIDDERS LEGAL RIGHTS.

If you have any complaints or questions about the Conditions of Sale, please contact your nearest customer services team.

Buyers' Premium and Charges

For all Sales categories excluding Arms & Armor, Coins & Medals, Motor Cars, Motorcycles, and Wine & Whisky:

Buyer's Premium Rates
25% on the first $100,000 of the Hammer Price
20% from $100,001 to $2,000,000 of the Hammer Price
12% on the excess over $2,000,000 of the Hammer Price

Payment Notices

Payment for purchases may be made in or by (a) cash, (b) cashier's check or money order, (c) personal check with approved credit drawn on a U.S. bank, (d) wire transfer or other immediate bank transfer, or (e) Visa, MasterCard, American Express or Discover credit, charge or debit card. A processing fee will be assessed on any returned checks. Please note that the amount of cash notes and cash equivalents that can be accepted from a given purchaser may be limited.

Shipping Notices

For information and estimates on domestic and international shipping as well as export licences please contact Bonhams Shipping Department.

Special Car Dealer Notices

Dealers license, number 49015

Contacts
  1. Mark Osborne
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    220 San Bruno Avenue
    San Francisco, United States 94103
    Work +1 415 503 3353
    FaxFax: +1 415 503 3300
  2. Motor Cars (US)
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    Work +1 415 391 4000
    FaxFax: +1 415 391 4040
  3. Rupert Banner
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    580 Madison Avenue
    New York, United States 10022
    Work +1 212 461 6515
    FaxFax: +1 917 206 1669
  4. Jakob Greisen
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    220 San Bruno Avenue
    San Francisco, United States 94103
    Work +1 415 503 3284
    FaxFax: +1 415 391 4040
  5. Eric Minoff
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    580 Madison Avenue
    New York, United States 10022
    Work +1 917 206 1630
    FaxFax: +1 917 206 1669
  6. David Swig
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    220 San Bruno Avenue
    San Francisco, United States 94103
    Work +1 415 503 3285
    FaxFax: +1 415 391 4040
  7. Evan Ide
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work Boston, United States
    Work +1 917 340 4657
  8. Nick Smith
    Specialist - Motor Cars
    Bonhams
    Work
    7601 W. Sunset Boulevard
    Los Angeles, United States 90046
    Work +1 323 436 5470
    FaxFax: +1 323 850 5843