Pear shaped banded agate with mask handles
Lot 53
A banded agate snuff bottle Imperial, Official School, attributed to the palace workshops, Beijing, 1740–1800
Sold for HK$ 114,000 (US$ 14,709) inc. premium
Lot Details
A banded agate snuff bottle
Imperial, Official School, attributed to the palace workshops, Beijing, 1740–1800
7.4cm high.

Footnotes

  • Treasury 2, no. 340


    條紋瑪瑙鼻煙壺
    頒賜類,推定為宮廷作坊作,1740~1800


    The Imperial Vase Agate

    Agate; very well hollowed with a flat lip and a recessed flat foot surrounded by a protruding flat footrim; carved with mask-and-ring handles
    Imperial, Official school, attributed to the palace workshops, Beijing, 1740–1800
    Height: 7.4 cm
    Mouth/lip: 0.68/1.22 cm
    Stopper: pearl; gilt-bronze collar
    Condition: workshop condition

    Provenance:
    Robert Hall (1996)
    Published:
    Treasury 2, no. 340

    Commentary:
    Clues as to the nature of undecorated bottles made at court are offered by this magnificent agate bottle. We are in no doubt that very large numbers of plain quartz bottles would have been produced at and for the court, as they were in glass and other materials, but the lack of distinctive decoration and the fact that there must have been many more private hardstone-carving workshops around the country than, say, glass factories, makes them far more difficult to identify. Form, hollowing, lip and foot styles, mouth-size, and in some cases specific materials are all we can go on. Working from decorated, inscribed, or reign-marked examples that can be reasonably attributed to imperial workshops, we can begin to build up the criteria for identifying the plainer examples. From this we can arrive at a series of imperial attributes for plain bottles. We must bear in mind that these attributes may also exist, either individually or even as a group on non-imperial wares, but despite this problem a clearer picture of the less obviously imperial production will emerge.

    This agate masterpiece is a step in that direction, and allows us tentatively to include a fairly large group of bottles within the imperial fold. There are many superbly made agate bottles with no more than mask handles of an imperial type that share the excellent and extensive hollowing of this example with similar neatly carved details and lovely material which, left plain, is allowed to assume a prominent aesthetic role.

    Here three features allow an imperial and palace workshop attribution. The mask handles are typical for the court, with exquisitely carved and finished, well-rounded masks, their formalized curls surrounding a bulbous pate, the high forehead with two curved lines carved into it, like empty parentheses, the lower jaw missing, the rings neat and rounded, set beneath a bulbous, broad nose. These are precisely the masks that appear on a wide range of palace glass bottles, on jade and a variety of other materials, many of which can be attributed to the court, and much more of which was also probably imperial (see also discussion under Treasury 2, no. 294 and for other similar handles, Treasury 2, nos. 277, 295 and 321). A second imperial feature is the lipped upper neck rim (see Treasury 1, no. 75) which is an even stronger indication of imperial stylistic habit when one considers the third feature, the shape of the bottle. Like so many palace forms, it is derived from ceramics, being a compressed danping (gall-bladder vase).

    The magnificent little late-Qianlong palace agate, Treasury 2, no. 356, is taken from the same shape and also has a lipped rim. The ceramic form would not normally have a lipped rim. It is simply a feature of snuff bottles at the court so common that it even gets applied in the snuff-bottle arts to forms that would otherwise not have it. With these clues to hand, we can now look at many examples with fresh eyes and see the likely imperial connection. The magnificent and famous agate which was the subject of the 1977 Hong Kong Museum of Art exhibition poster and is now in the J & J Collection (Moss, Graham, and Tsang 1993, no. 116) has identical mask-and-ring handles. It is similarly well hollowed and detailed at the foot and lip, and is of the same sort of range of material. Many, many more now fall into a similar category.

    Apart from its valuable clues for imperial attribution, this is one of the great masterpieces of agate snuff-bottle carving. A delightful piece of material, suffused with banding in different colours and of different patterns and textures, it is exquisitely carved into a rare and extremely elegant form for a snuff bottle. The mask handles have been placed with unquestionably confident balance. To analyse this form is to understand that had they been placed only a millimetre or two higher or lower it simply would not have worked anything like as well. Miraculously, considering the differences in dynamics of the banding on each of the main sides, the artist has also managed to achieve a perfect balance not only with the form but with the natural decoration, offsetting the formality of the handles and their positioning with the asymmetrical but powerful lines of the banding on each side. It is even rewarding to read the natural markings as landscape imagery in the ink-play mode (see Treasury 2, no. 274) where there are many different possibilities.

    One possibility would be to see the foreground as a broad river on both sides with a plain beyond and mountains in the distance, or as steep cliffs with mountains immediately beyond. With our modern flight-inspired perspective, one could even see it as an aerial view of a broad river snaking through a plain, although that would have been an unlikely intention at the time. In any of these the vertical streak low on one side is a tree, the dark streak straddling one narrow and one main side above the mask-handle possibly a hawk or eagle, possibly even two, in flight, allowing the aerial view. However it is interpreted, it is a delight.

    It also has a splendidly matched old stopper, probably not the original since bottles of this sort were not really intended to have an original stopper in the sense of one inevitable stopper. Pearls set in gilt-bronze are unusual, and in this case the two colours perfectly match the colours in the striations. It is interesting to note, however, that because of the vase-form, a ceramic form not intended for stoppering, this is one of the few snuff bottles that is formally satisfying without any stopper. Very few bottles seem anything but glaringly incomplete without their stoppers and, as a rule, those that survive formally without are derived from other arts, or, of course, animal-or vegetable- forms. The average snuff bottle, with a normal neck, looks like fish out of water without a stopper.


    御製花瓶瑪瑙

    條紋瑪瑙;掏膛特別整齊,平唇、平面斂底、突出平底圈足;二側雕獸首啣環耳

    頒賜類,推定為宮廷作坊作:1740~1800
    高:7.4 厘米
    口經/唇經:0.68/1.22 厘米
    蓋:珍珠,描金青銅蓋
    狀態敘述:出坊狀態

    來源:
    羅伯特.霍爾(1996)
    文獻﹕
    Treasury 2, 編號340

    說明:
    這件瑪瑙傑作代表著很多無圖案的硬石煙壺,它們除了御製風的獸首耳以外,內膛掏得很完整,材料自身的自然形態特徵也具有審美意義,雖然我們不能斷定它們都是御製品,但這些特色可當作試探法的標記,有助於將來確定御用作坊所製硬石煙壺的範圍。

    本壺的獸首啣環耳是宮廷作坊風的,有不少可確定為宮廷作坊產品的玻璃煙壺、玉石煙壺等為旁證。其特色包括﹕雕刻精工,形式化卷毛圍繞球形、中部刻二括號的額頭,無下巴,球形寬闊鼻子下的環耳雕得圓圓而完整。可參照Treasury 2, 編號294的論述和獸首啣環耳類似的277、295、321編號。

    本壺唇緣的突出也是宮廷作坊產品的特徵,再說,本壺的形式像很多御製品,源於瓷器,如本壺為扁膽瓶形。

    華麗的小瑪瑙煙壺Treasury 2,編號356的形式也可以追溯到膽瓶,也具有唇緣。瓷瓶平常不具唇緣,但是衍生的宮廷作坊煙壺習慣性地就來個唇緣。用這些線索來再看很多煙壺,我們能發覺它們來自宮廷。香港藝術館1977展覽海報上的瑪瑙器(後歸J & J珍藏;參見Moss, Graham, and Tsang 1993,編號116)具同形的獸首啣環耳,掏膛也很完整,底與唇都呈類似的修飾,材料也是同類的。意識到這一批的特色,我們會把非常多的煙壺歸納到同一個類目。

    本壺也是瑪瑙鼻煙壺中大出色的製作,不但是材料優美,也是形式高雅少見。獸首啣環耳的安置沒有一絲一毫高的差錯,壺形之玲瓏雅致與瑪瑙絢麗流動互相襯托,連古蓋也配合得很好。無論蓋子大概不是原件,反正那種煙壺本來不是配合一定的蓋子的。鑲嵌描金青銅座的珍珠不多見,而且蓋子兩部分的顏色和瑪瑙橫紋的顏色相配適宜。有意思的是,因為本壺的形式源於本來不帶蓋的瓶形器,把蓋子拿掉了對它的整體狀態也沒甚麼損害。一般的煙壺沒有蓋子就顯得不齊全,煙壺只有形式來自其他藝術或人、獸、菜等物,才能無蓋而不失色。
Activities
Auction information

This sale is now finished. If you are interested in consigning in future sales, please contact the specialist department. If you have queries about lots purchased in this sale, please contact customer services.

Buyers' Obligations

ALL BIDDERS MUST AGREE THAT THEY HAVE READ AND UNDERSTOOD BONHAMS' CONDITIONS OF SALE AND AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THEM, AND AGREE TO PAY THE BUYER'S PREMIUM AND ANY OTHER CHARGES MENTIONED IN THE NOTICE TO BIDDERS. THIS AFFECTS THE BIDDERS LEGAL RIGHTS.

If you have any complaints or questions about the Conditions of Sale, please contact your nearest customer services team.

Buyers' Premium and Charges

For all Sales categories excluding Wine:

Buyer's Premium Rates
25% on the first HKD800,000 of the Hammer Price
20% from HKD800,001 to HKD1,000,000 of the Hammer Price
12% on the excess over HKD1,000,000 of the Hammer Price.

Shipping Notices

For information and estimates on domestic and international shipping as well as export licences please contact Bonhams Shipping Department.

Similar items
An inscribed agate snuff bottle Official School, 1730-1850 An agate 'Sun Wukong' snuff bottle Official School, 1760–1850 A banded agate snuff bottle Qing dynasty, 1760-1880 A carnelian-agate snuff bottle 1730-1880 An inside-painted 'hair-crystal' snuff bottle Ye Zhongsan, dated 1905 (the bottle 1740-1860) A banded agate snuff bottle  19th century